Sunday, August 25, 2013

The Flowering of Life

From my career as a technical writer in biotechnology—first with a pharmaceutical company making biological products from recombinant DNA, then with an instrument company making tools for genetic analysis—I have remained fascinated with life’s processes and how they developed.1

The first life on Earth was microscopic: bacteria and single-celled organisms. They appeared about 3.6 billion years ago, just shortly after the solar system and the planets formed, and just about as soon as the Earth’s surface and atmosphere cooled enough to allow life processes to form without being cooked. The planet’s original atmosphere had no free oxygen—that came later, with photosynthesis in plants. The earliest bacteria loved hot environments and made their living by converting sulfur and carbon into energy-bearing chemicals.

With no cell nucleus and no nuclear processes, the DNA of microbes—called the “prokaryotes”—is present throughout the cell body. All of their DNA is continuously being transcribed to RNA and translated to proteins. That is, the cell makes all of its component parts all the time, and so it endlessly expands. However, the cell wall or membrane is not infinitely elastic. It would simply split open and spill its contents if it did not find a way to copy and separate those strands of DNA, attach the new copies to different parts of the cell membrane, and then divide in an orderly fashion to make two daughter cells in a process called “binary fission.” Microbes grow and divide and grow again by sheer necessity. The growth of microbes is uncontrolled—except by the availability of water, light, and nutrients—unless adverse conditions intervene.2

This was the nature of life on Earth for about 1.5 billion years. Then the first “eukaryotes” appeared. Single cells had started banding together into primitive organisms—the first being a coiled, multi-cellular algae found in iron formations in Michigan dating back 2.1 billion years. Eventually, the intracellular DNA was collected in a single structure within the cell body, the nucleus, which enabled selective gene promotion and cellular specialization.3 And other complex structures call organelles were suddenly found inside the cell body—likely acquired as separate, single cells themselves which were absorbed by the parent. Probably the most familiar of these is the mitochondrion, which processes food energy into the cell’s basic energy molecule, adenosine triphosphate. The mitochondrion has its own DNA, separate from the cell’s nuclear material.4

Life on this level proceeded for another billion years or so. And then, about 500 million year ago the natural world exploded: multi-celled organisms diversified rapidly, and the major animal phyla all appeared within about 20 million years. And all of these animals are related.

The clue to this relationship can be found in the similar molecular structures, drawing on identical protein-coding genes, shared by widely divergent genuses. A specific example can be found in the work of Eric Davidson, a researcher at the California Institute of Technology. He and his team have studied the development of sea urchin embryos on an almost minute-by-minute basis after fertilization. He found that once the blastula—the globe of cells resulting from divisions in the fertilized egg—was formed, cells in different parts of the globe began differentiating.5 Some became the calcium-secreting cells that would form the creature’s skeleton, others became the precursors to the gut and the outer skin. All of this was based on the cell’s original position in one or another quadrant of the blastula.

Further, Davidson studied the genetic activity inside those cells and discovered that one patch of DNA always transcribed a small RNA strand that never left the nucleus but instead found and annealed to another part of the DNA. That triggered transcription of a second RNA strand, which then triggered a third RNA strand, and on and on. Depending on position in the blastula and timing, these RNA strands branched along different networks that defined the particular cell type and its activity. Davidson then studied embryo development in other animals that had not shared an ancestor with the sea urchin in about 300 million years and found the same early development networks. That means humans probably share the early stages of this development pattern, too, which then diverges depending on the DNA in our genome and the genes that are finally triggered to create cellular proteins.6

In the dry language of genetic analysts, the roots of life—its development from simple to complex chemistries, and from simple to complex structures—are “highly conserved.”

But the point of this meditation is actually the timeline itself. Life arose almost immediately on this planet, 3.6 billion years ago.7 It took about half that time, 1.5 billion years, to progress from simple, single-celled prokaryotes to the more complex, multi-celled eukaryotes. And about a quarter of that time, 1 billion years, to develop complex and highly diversified physical forms. Finally, only in the last fraction of life’s time on Earth, about 65 million years during the age of mammals, after the Chicxulub meteor strike wiped out the dinosaurs and let our primitive shrew-like ancestors evolve, did truly complex, non-instinctual, self-perceiving mental structures—human-scale intelligence—develop. The simplest advances took the longest time; the more complex advances took less and less time at each stage. And the part of the story we have the hardest time understanding—development of our own brains—took almost no time at all in the geologic record.

You would think life would progress the other way around: baby steps coming fast at first, and then the development of an ever richer complexity taking longer and longer. The fact that life arose in shorter and shorter timeframes like this tells me the driver was not some implicit plan or guiding intelligence. Complexity has a power of its own. Richness and diversity beget more and more richness and diversity. It reminds me of the sweep of science and technology: since the first scientific discoveries during the Enlightenment, our understanding and application has been moving faster and faster.8

Isn’t this is a wonderful time to be alive?

1. See for example, Evolution and Intelligent Design from February 24, 2013, and DNA is Everywhere from September 9, 2010.

2. For example, if conditions suddenly become too extreme—too little food, too cold, too dry—the single cell can pack its DNA into a tight, tough little package called a spore and release it to await better conditions. The cell dies but the DNA travels onward. The decision to form a spore is automatic, driven by transcription factors in the DNA that respond to certain chemical cues.

3. Among the various specializations was the differentiation of body parts and individuals into male and female. And so sexual reproduction was born.

4. You don’t get your mitochondria from both parents. Instead, you inherit it strictly from the egg donated by your mother; all mitochondria come from the female line. Also, you have many more copies of the mitochondria with its specific DNA scattered within a single cell than you have copies of the cell’s nuclear DNA. This is why isolating and studying mitochondrial DNA is usually easier in ancient or damaged tissues than studying the nuclear DNA.

5. For illustrations of this process, see Davidson College’s “Introduction to Sea Urchin Development” and Stanford University’s “Sea Urchin Embryology.”

6. The preceding paragraphs are copied from my earlier blog “Gene Deserts” and the Future of Medicine from December 5, 2010—another meditation on the nature of DNA.

7. And yet the complex chemistry that enables self-replicating life to function in the first place—the interplay of ribose sugar rings and phosphate bonds in DNA and RNA, and their intricate mediation between amino acids and proteins—seems to have been present almost from the beginning. As noted in Communicating with Aliens from July 28, 2013, neither the fossil record nor the far-flung examples of life on this planet suggest any evolution of this DNA/RNA/protein coding system from a more primitive variant. That suggests it either arose awfully fast and quickly outcompeted any other basis for life—or it came here in its fully developed form from somewhere else, either seeded on this planet or left inadvertently as a microbe on some astronaut’s glove.

8. See The Dollar Value of Technical Advances from May 5, 2013.

Sunday, August 18, 2013

Enigmas of the Big Bang

Light is funny stuff. You can think of it as a particle, called a “photon,” traveling in a wave-like fashion, undulating up-and-down (or, to be fair, from side to side) along its established path. Or you can think of it as the wave itself, but with a separately measurable quantity, or “quantum,” of energy equivalent to a photon’s basic properties. Light has all the properties of both tiny particles and elongated waves.1

Light comes in many wavelengths, which are the distance from one “upward” swing of the wave to the next. That distance from peak to peak defines its frequency. The closer the peaks are, the more energy the photon or quantum carries.

Light is not just the visible light by which we see the world—sunlight, moonlight, electric light—but all forms of electromagnetic radiation. These include the long wavelengths of radio and television signals, which vary between 10 meters (about 30 feet) and one meter (about a yard) from peak to peak. Next up the energy scale come microwaves of about one centimeter (hundredth of a meter) peak to peak, which are useful in both long-distance communications and rapid cookery. More energetic still is the energy we feel as heat from a fireplace or a glowing filament, which falls in the “infrared” (or “below the red”) wavelengths of about one micrometer (millionth of a meter). Above that lies the deep end of the visible spectrum, the red end at about 700 nanometers (billionths of a meter), which then proceeds through the various colors of light you can break out with a prism to the deep blue or violet end of the spectrum at about 400 nanometers. Beyond that is the “ultraviolet,” at between 100 and 10 nanometers. And if you go further into the shortest measured wavelengths you get the x-rays at about 1 nanometer, energetic enough to pass through soft materials like flesh and blood but not through denser bones, and then the gamma rays at one ten-billionth of a meter, a unit called an ångstrom after the Swedish physicist, which are small enough and energetic enough to knock around your DNA and make life-changing mutations.

Since all light travels at the speed of, well, light, the amount of energy in a burst of electromagnetic radiation—whether it originates as radio and visible light waves coming from the fusion of a main sequence star like our Sun, or as X-rays from a rapidly spinning pulsar—does not affect its speed, only its wavelength. The speed of light or any electromagnetic radiation remains constant.2 And its energy level remains unchanged no matter how far the light has traveled, nor how long it has been in transit. Light does not “get tired” and lose its original energy.3 This is because, according to Einstein’s theory of relativity, for anything traveling at the speed of light, time has essentially stopped. The only way it can lose energy is to interact with matter along its route.

We live inside a vast machine called the universe. Think of a microbe sitting on the face of a gear inside an old watch—or rather, something much smaller than a microbe sitting on a gear in a clockworks much larger than Big Ben’s. The gears, the escapement, the hands of the clock are all moving. But, from the perspective of our microbe’s busy little life, the movement is so slight, the action so slow, that the clock appears to be frozen in time, motionless, even immovable.

Like that microbe on a gear, we sit on the face of our own planet. We can sense a bit of motion from the Sun’s rise and fall in the sky, the cycle of days, the motions of other planets and their satellites against the night sky, and the turning of the background star field throughout the year. But the rest of the universe—including those fixed stars—might have been painted on the inside surface of a distant sphere. Not until about four hundred years ago did we finally figure out that the Earth was not the center of all this motion but was itself moving like the other planets around the Sun. And not until about a century ago did we figure out that some stars were near to us, distant suns moving in a system called the Milky Way, while some of those bright patches in the night sky were actually other systems of stars, called galaxies, with their own proper motion. We now estimate that we live in a universe containing between 100 to 200 billion galaxies, each containing—if the current estimate of our own Milky Way is accurate—between 200 and 400 billion stars.

All of them are in motion. But the movement is so slight from our perspective—a microbe sitting on the face of a gear far removed from the real action—that we must detect this motion by means other than direct observation.

One such means is by measuring the light coming from distant galaxies, generated by stars which—because of the quality of their light and their occasional explosions—we believe to be similar to those in our own galaxy. In all of these distant stars, the light is shifted somewhat along the normal spectrum. In most cases the light has appeared to lose energy and shifted to the red in proportion to their distance.4 Since, as noted above, light cannot “become tired,” something else must be going on. Astronomer Edwin Hubble proposed in 19295 that the red shift was due to the Doppler effect: the light was dropping in pitch, like a locomotive whistle falling off as the train moves away from us, because the universe is actually expanding. That’s one piece of evidence.

If the universe is expanding, then at one time it must have been smaller. In fact, if you calculate backward from that rate of expansion, about 13 billion years ago it must have had almost no dimension at all. So was born the Big Bang theory: that the universe began in a single explosion of an infinitely dense, infinitely hot piece of matter, smaller than a proton, which contained all the mass of those hundreds of billions of galaxies each containing hundreds of billions of stars, plus the stuff we cannot see in other galaxies like dust, asteroids, planets, and brown dwarf stars. The Big Bang theory—which today is accepted as the one true origin story—is an inference from General Relativity and Hubble’s examination of starlight.

Then, in 1965, two Bell Labs engineers working on a microwave antenna in New Jersey that was designed for radio astronomy and satellite communications, Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson, discovered an annoying hum. It was a microwave signal of such low frequency that it equated to a temperature of 3.2 degrees Kelvin, barely above the absolute freezing point of all matter. It was a bit of static that no amount of tuning or antenna cleaning could eliminate. They suggested that the hum was the residue of the energy released in the Big Bang, now red shifted almost completely off the scale.6 That’s the second piece of evidence.

Since then, maps of this background radiation covering the entire sky—made first by NASA’s Cosmic Background Explorer (COBE) satellite between 1989 and 1996, then refined by the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) from 2001 to 2010, and now further refined by the European Space Agency’s Planck probe in 2013—have shown variations which suggest how denser areas of that radiation might have formed into galactic groups. Analysis of the data also support the contention that the universe not only expanded from a single point but also that, at one time early in its growth, the universe inflated rapidly to yield the dimensions we can perceive today, and further that the expansion is now accelerating under the influence of some repulsive force that physicists call “dark energy.”

But, as microbes sitting on a distant and relatively unimportant gear in the clockwork, all of this activity must be inferred from the analysis of starlight and radio waves, using a great deal of human-created mathematics and a bit of human imagination. I’m not entirely comfortable with this commonly accepted origin story. It’s probably a true interpretation of the evidence. And I admittedly haven’t made a lifetime study of the more esoteric aspects of cosmology and mathematics to either confirm or deny it. But I maintain there is also much we still don’t understand about three of the underlying components of the story: the exact nature and structure of empty space, of time, and of the binding force that mediates between them, gravity.7

Still, I will note some oddities about the hypothetical explosion represented by the disintegration and scattering of the infinitely dense, infinitely hot8 particle at the center of the story of our universe:

First, the Big Bang may not necessarily have resulted from conditions of incredible temperature and pressure. When a spacecraft vents wastes into supposedly structured but empty space—a vacuum—it only takes 14 pounds of pressure per square inch inside the cabin to create a fairly energetic eruption. Would not the introduction of even a small amount of structured material into the unstructured nothingness of the pre-Bang void result in an infinite-seeming explosion?9

Second, the Big Bang may not even have been hot. When gas under pressure expands into space, that expansion actually cools the molecules, because their internal energy is used to spread them over a larger volume. You can feel this when you put your hand into an aerosol spray or the discharge of a CO2 fire extinguisher. Why would the Big Bang have operated differently? The Big Bang would have been a cold event.

Third, the Big Bang may not have had much to do with events in the supposedly “structured” space we encounter today. Until space was formed by the addition of matter, adding dimension and distance to the ultimate void, time would not have been operable. The starting point of the Big Bang would have been both timeless and dimensionless. If there is no distance and no time, then speed—which is a function of the two measurement systems working together—cannot exist. So to describe the speed of the universe’s initial expansion at the instant of the Big Bang or during its inflationary period immediately afterward is meaningless. To quote the old joke, “Time is God’s way of keeping everything from happening at once.” But in a dimensionless non-space, everything does happen at once, which is really the same as not happening at all.

Fourth, the Big Bang might not have occurred anywhere in particular. To understand this, we need a thought experiment from everyday life. Imagine four people sitting at a card table on the fifty yard line of a football field. Now a bomb under the table explodes and throws two of them off to the sidelines and two of them back to the twenty yard line at either end of the field. If you asked each person where the bomb was, he would look around at the chalk lines in the grass, point to the fifty yard line, and say, “Over there!” Now imagine the same four sitting at a table in a dark room of unknown dimensions. The bomb goes off and throws everyone an unknowable distance in an unknowable direction with no floor to record the impact of their landing. Ask each person where the bomb went off, and he would point to his feet: “Right here!” Without a reference for the origin in space-time coordinates, the original Big Bang was “right here” for every point in the newly expanded universe. Right in my back yard. Right here between my fingertips.

I accept that the Big Bang is the most logical explanation of the phenomena of radiant energy that we see around us today in the forms of starlight and the microwave background. The Big Bang’s initial properties are derived from our rigorous study of these phenomena and their analysis using advanced intellectual tools such as mathematics and theories based on observed laws of motion and thermodynamics. But I don’t have to like the Big Bang as an explanation, because it takes us into realms that are meaningless. The conditions of the Big Bang are at once infinite and nonexistent. They are conditions that not only can’t be studied but also can’t be understood in terms of the very laws of physics that suggest them.

My nose suggests we’re missing something. My hind brain suggests it’s something obvious. But I just can’t say what it might be.

1. In the classic dual-slit experiment performed by physicist Thomas Young (1773-1829) to prove the wavelike nature of light, shine a beam of focused light such as from a flashlight or laser onto a card that has one or more slits in it and then beyond that to a screen behind the card. If the card has just one slit, the beam shines on the screen at full intensity, although it is spread out in a diffraction pattern. But if the card has two slits side by side, the beams that get through it interfere with each other, creating a pattern of alternating light and dark areas on the screen.
       A similar interference pattern occurs if an ocean wave rolls through a breakwater with two entrances: the collision of the two parts of the wave that make it through the breakwater interferes with the pattern of the original wave, making the water inside the harbor choppy and confused, resulting in separate wave pulses breaking against the inner wharf.
       We can understand this interference if the light is made up of many photons all traveling in the same direction with the same original wavelength or intensity. But this interference pattern also appears if only one photon is passed through either slit. True, the particle hits the screen in only one particular place. But if you send many individual photons through the slits over a period of time, as if you were spraying them with individual machinegun bullets, the individual hits will eventually build up an interference pattern on the screen. Even though the individual photons exist at separate points in time, each one acts as if it was going through both slits at once and interfering with itself. I told you light was funny stuff.
       If it helps, don’t try to think of photons as particles, like tiny bullets or BBs or bits of solid stuff like protons or electrons. After all, the photon has no mass, except for the momentum imparted by its energy. Instead, think of the photon as a quantum or discrete and measurable—although very tiny—“packet” of energy that moves in a wave-like fashion.

2. Depending on the medium, of course. The usual speed of light, at 186,282 miles per second (or 299,793 kilometers per second), is the speed in vacuum. It is slightly slower by a trivial amount when traveling through a transparent medium like air, water, or glass.

3. If light did simply “get tired,” such as by losing energy through collisions with stray atoms in interstellar or intergalactic space, then the light would be scattered and the images of distant stars and galaxies would appear with a fuzziness that no amount of optical resolution could fix. The “tired light” theory also does not account for the time dilations we can observe in the universe. For example, a nearby supernova may take 20 days to decay, but a similar type of star exploding in a distant galaxy may appear to take twice as long to go through the same process.

4. In a few cases, the light from distant galaxies has appeared to gain energy and shifted to the blue end of the spectrum. These blue-shifted galaxies do not invalidate the expansion of the universe. Instead, they are simply objects whose proper motion towards us cancels or reverses the red shift due to cosmic expansion.

5. Although the expansion of the universe is attributed to Hubble, who codified it as a law, he merely observed it and confirmed its existence from the observed red shift. The expansion was predicted by Einstein’s General Relativity, and the math was already worked out by Belgian priest and astronomer Georges Lemaître in 1927. Ten years earlier, American astronomer Vesto Slipher had observed the red shift of various stars and suggested it was related to their velocity. Everyone stands on the shoulders of giants.

6. Once again, they were only confirming something that others—in this case American scientists Ralph Alpher and Robert Herman—had predicted almost two decades earlier.

7. See my complementary blogs “Three Things We Don’t Know About Physics” fromDecember 30, 2012 and January 6, 2013.

8. To begin with, the concept of infinity and its attribution—as in “infinitely dense, infinitely hot”—should be a red flag. Infinity is a human construct, embedded in mathematics, to represent numbers that are simply beyond counting. We used to think the universe was infinite in time and space, but we now have a timing mechanism that gives it a very finite age, 13 billion years. (Not so big a number, when you consider that we now measure the national debt in trillions.) And the universe’s physical dimensions of length, breadth, and depth are “infinite” only because we cannot detect or derive a starting or an ending point. In those terms, every sphere from a billiard ball to the event horizon of a galactic black hole has an “infinite” surface area.

9. I use the word “unstructured nothingness” because in the current view of physics the vacuum of space appears to have structure. While the Michelson-Morley experiment of 1887 disproved the notion that empty space was filled with a universal and invisible substance called “luminiferous ether,” empty space still has something going for it. First, it has three dimensions with which we can orient ourselves and perhaps many more dimensions about which we can theorize but not yet detect. Second, space is presumed to be bathed in the fields associated with various quantum particles—electromagnetic fields, gravity fields, and so on. Third, it is presumed to be continually popping off pairs of matter/antimatter particles that appear and then silently, invisibly annihilate one another. And fourth, it appears to generate a “dark energy” that drives the expansion of the universe. Space may be empty but it is hardly uninteresting

Sunday, August 11, 2013

Emergent Properties

A couple of years ago, in one of the scientific journals,1 I came across a concept that was then new to me: “emergent property.” I forget the original context of the article, but the author used the example of a tabletop to illustrate the idea. From our perspective at the human scale, the top is a flat plane, but at the atomic level, the flat surface disappears into a lumpy swarm of molecules. Aficionados of fractal imagery will understand this perfectly: any natural feature like the slope of a hill or shore of a coast can be broken down into smaller and smaller curves and angles, endlessly subject to refinement. In fractal geometry, which is driven by simple equations, the large curves mirror the small curves ad infinitum.

The emergent property is a matter of perspective, but that doesn’t make it simply an illusion or something not-real. The flatness of the tabletop is just as real—and more useful for setting out silverware and plates—than the churning atoms that actually compose it. The hill and its slope are just as real—and more useful for climbing—than the myriad tiny angles and curves, the surfaces of the grains of sand and bits of rock, that underlie the slope.

Emergent property works on greater scales, too. From space the Earth presents as a nearly perfect sphere, a blue-white marble decorated with flashes of green and brown, but still quite smooth. That spherical shape only becomes apparent from a great distance. Viewed from the surface, it’s easy enough for the eye to see a flat plane bounded by the horizon and to focus on hills and valleys as objects of great stature which, from a distance of millions of miles, do not even register as wrinkles.2, 3

The concept of emergent property still haunts me when I look at a piece of polished steel or glass: however bright, smooth, and reflective the surface may appear, it’s actually quite rough at the atomic level. Moreover, the surface is pitted with gaps, the empty spaces between atoms that are not molecularly bonded and so held apart by the positive or negative charges created by their outermost electron shells.4

Emergent properties come into play only when the action of thousands, millions, or billions of separate and distinct elements are perceived and treated as a single entity. “Forest” is an emergent property of thousands of individual trees. The concept of emergent properties can be extremely useful to describe some of the situations and events that we wrestle with daily.

Consider the complexity and intuitive vagueness that we encounter when dealing with the human “mind” and its complement, the “personality.” Point to a single thought or the result of a single firing neuron and you lose the concept of mind. Conversely, you can know a person intimately and believe you understand his or her deepest nature, and yet trying to describe the whole person by mentioning one, two, or even a handful of traits leaves you frustrated. The mind is an emergent property of the flow of sensations, reactions, and thoughts occurring in human awareness. For that matter, thoughts can be described as an emergent property of electrical signals in the brain. One signal does not make up a complete thought, only the interaction of many signals. One thought does not make up a mind, only the interaction and remembrance of many thoughts and experiences over time. Similarly, one choice or action, a single like or dislike, one spoken word or a telling silence, does not make up the personality.5 The nature of the individual only emerges as the summation of actions and choices held and compared in the perceiver’s memory.

The shape and function of cells are emergent properties of proteins orchestrated by the action of DNA. One gene or protein does not make a cell, only the interaction of many proteins. Similarly, the body and its functions is the collective property of millions or billions of cells. If you peel back the layers of cells—skin, fat, flesh, blood, bone—you do not arrive at a “true” center that is the “real” body. By taking away, you simply remove the reality of the emergent property in favor of the bits and pieces that comprise it. Similarly, if you peel back the layers of an onion, you eventually come to a green shoot with a hollow center, but that is no more the nature of the onion than the hollow ventricles of a human heart are the center of the human’s being.

Climate may be an emergent property of weather: patterns that recur with the seasons, storm and sunlight, evaporation and precipitation, high pressure pushing in behind low pressure. But one thunderstorm, or one season of storms, does not make a climate, only year after year of patterns recurring with variation. And one temporary input such as infalling solar radiation or a spike in humidity does not make a thunderstorm, only the interaction of many inputs working together.

The whole world around us, everything we can see at a human level, is the emergent property of molecular events. One molecular bond, joining or breaking, does not create the world, only the interaction of many bonds. In this case, the probability of any single event is the sum of the probabilities of the contributing molecular events. Similarly, a galaxy is the emergent property of its stars, and the shape of the universe an emergent property of the galaxies and the masses they contain.

The key point here is that looking for or arguing about the importance of one thought, one gene, one weather input, one molecular event in relation to the whole is usually futile. In some rare cases, a single gene mutation may give rise to a defective cell, or a single hurricane may temporarily change the weather over a region for a few weeks or a month. But among millions of mutations and thousands of storms the emergent property is … stability.

Systems tend to evolve in stability. Disruptions like thunderstorms or genetic mutations or temper tantrums tend to spend themselves and then the system returns to stability. The notion that single effects can trigger chain reactions, build momentum, and ultimately take over the system is an error of perception. Yes, a seed crystal dropped into a supersaturated salt solution can cause a sudden precipitation of solid grains. Yes, quickly bringing together two hemispheres of uranium each containing a high concentration of the U-235 isotope can cause an impressive explosion. Yes, repeatedly insulting the human genome with bursts of ionizing radiation or chemical irritants can cause a cancer to form. And yes, an incidence of frustration and resulting temper tantrum may herald a psychotic break. But in each case, the triggering effect exploits an instability—supersaturation, concentration, underlying genetic or psychological propensity—that leads to the sudden change. Systems don’t usually run away by themselves. And when they appear to do so, then the sudden deviation is an emergent property of the trigger impinging on systemic instability.

Reality is simply an emergent property of a sum of causes leading to a sum of effects. The universe generates and regenerates itself through complexity and interaction. Choirs of angels sing on atomic pinheads. We have so much to discover, to learn, and to appreciate!

1. And no, I don’t have a reference for it.

2. The popular notion that the sphericity of the Earth was only discovered by Columbus’s sailing west to go east is a myth. The Greek mathematician Eratosthenes measured the circumference of the planet in 240 B.C. by comparing the angle of the noonday sun and the shadows it cast at the summer solstice in his hometown of Alexandria and at the city of Aswan in southern Egypt. And sailors have long been able to intuit the curvature of the surface, because they can see ships disappear over the horizon—going “hull down”—while their masts and sails stay plainly in sight. And then again, a sailor who climbs his own mast can see farther, and see more of that ship on the horizon, than one standing on the deck. The planet has given us clues to its true nature since antiquity.

3. The surface roughness of the Earth, compared to the surfaces of objects manufactured to high tolerances like ball bearings and billiard balls, is a matter of some conjecture. The Earth’s surface deviations from, say, the Marianas Trench (6.8 miles deep) to the top of Mount Everest (5.5 miles high), are about 100 times the deepest scratches on a cue ball that would still be allowed in tournament play. So the planet would make a poor ball bearing in some giant’s Erector Set. But if you could pick it up and handle it with that giant’s fingers, the planet would feel almost as smooth.
       Of course, surface roughness is different from the planet’s roundness, and there the Earth is quite distorted, or oblate, due to the pull generated by its spin. The diameter measured across the equator is greater than the diameter measured along the axis of spin by about 27 miles. But that deviation is still small enough that it only became apparent when we started going into orbit and taking detailed measurements.

4. An old thought experiment in physics holds that if, by some vanishingly rare coincidence of alignment, the empty space between the atoms in your finger could momentarily line up with the atoms comprising the tabletop, and vice versa, you could push your fingertip right through the surface. (Of course, if those gaps suddenly shifted while your finger was so inserted, the result would be quite painful.) But then, you can never really touch the table’s surface at all, because the electron charges of those surface atoms repel your fingertip in the same way they repel the other atoms in the tabletop.

5. And yet, as every novelist knows, a single choice, action, or word can have great effect in the world of affairs and change the course of a lifetime.

Sunday, August 4, 2013

Beauty Beneath the Beast

I own an iPhone 4. I admit unashamedly that I love it for its pure physical beauty. The elegant, brushed-steel band wraps two panes of black-black, hardened glass and supports a few slightly raised and rounded buttons bearing minimal markings. The object’s proportions are perfect, like the monolith in 2001: A Space Odyssey, except that where the monolith had pointed corners and sharp edges, this phone has rounded curves reminiscent of the serifs on the calligraphy Steven Jobs once studied. Aside from the tiny amount of travel in the steel buttons, the phone as a machine has no moving parts. It looks, feels, and functions like something a visitor from the 23rd century just happened to leave behind.1

For years I carried around a notebook and pen, because a writer needs those capture to random thoughts—the flood tide of any work in progress—and a pocket calculator, because I just can’t do fast and accurate math standing up. About fifteen years ago I added a cell phone to the carry-all collection, and it was the approximate size and shape of hotdog bun. Ever since, I’ve been progressing through the technological solutions, first moving to a Japanese “personal data assistant,” or PDA, with an awkward and sometimes incomprehensible operating system. I carried that with a notebook as backup plus the phone. I later moved through a series of Palms devices, with their angular and often-wrong writing system. All of these were bulky units with strangely stylized angles, bevels, and bezels on their cases. I didn’t know it then, but I was groping my way toward the elegance and multifunctionality of the iPhone.2

Which brings me to the curiosity. Brushed steel and hardened glass are fairly durable. Reviewers whom I read before buying the phone said they just dropped it in a briefcase and walked off; it still looked pristine after a couple of weeks of rattling around under such casual handling. But at the point of purchase I bought a protective case for it. I did this with my previous iPhones, which had somewhat more delicate plastic cases and unhardened glass. I’ve now gone through a couple of these case protectors for the iPhone 4.3 Some have looked like those bulky clear-plastic boxes into which stores lock CDs and software, to make them harder to shoplift. The most recent case is an Otterbox, which covers the phone with rubber fenders, exposed latches, and clunky bezels. Supposedly you can drive a car over an Otterbox and it will protect the phone within from damage. However, I don’t expect to drop my phone in the driveway and leave it long enough for a car to find it.

Recently I was talking with a friend and extolling the elegance of Apple’s design concepts in a conversation about motorcycle design. He pointed to his own iPhone on the desk to prove the point—except that it was covered with an Otterbox. I pulled out mine, and we laughed about it. We both had bought a Jaguar for is sleekness and design elegance, then covered it with the body of a Humvee to protect it from everyday life. If we want to actually enjoy the Jaguar’s elegance, we have to spend some finite number of minutes disassembling the Humvee—and then we’ll put it right back on.

If I had a patron god, it would be Vishnu, the Preserver. I love beautiful technology, but I hate wear and tear, nicks and scratches. With my motorcycles, I am obsessive about cleaning and waxing to protect the clearcoat that protects the paint underneath.4 I have put bulky film lens protectors and polycarbonate guards bound with sticky dots over elegantly shaped headlight modules to protect them from flying stones. If I actually drove a Jaguar, I would probably be one of those people who cover the front end with a black Naugahyde vinyl “bra” to avoid stone chips, although I would always worry about dust collecting under the cover and abrading the clearcoat. I draw the line at sealing a new couch inside those cold and sticky vinyl slipcovers, but I am liberal with the Scotchgard.®

Why do we do this? Wouldn’t it be better to simply enjoy the object in use? By the time it got old and scuffed, it would probably be time to upgrade to a newer model with more functionality anyway. Why this obsession with protecting beauty by hiding it beneath a beast?

Perhaps the obsession is because our appreciation of the thing’s beauty is purely a private matter. We don’t actually acquire a sleek smartphone or a curvaceous motorcycle to impress the other people in our lives. If that were the case, we would display the object proudly. Instead, we hide it away because we love it for itself. We hold the memory of its beauty in our minds while living with the hideous case. Perhaps we even see the beauty through the layers of protective plastic and film and trick ourselves into believing that we continue to live in the presence of a gorgeous objet d’art.

If we do not actually have to see the beauty to appreciate it, then do we necessarily need to own it? Why not appreciate the elegant design of the phone or curve of the gas tank and fenders in the store, cherish that memory, then buy a clunky old plastic phone or a dented second-hand motorcycle to use in everyday life? I would like to believe this is what others might do, but I lack the power of self-hypnosis to make this a satisfying approach. And I fear that the people who buy the clunky phone and dented motorcycle never loved the beauty of form in the first place.

My love for the form and function engenders my need to possess it physically and use it, although with ephemeral protection. Sometimes I will buy the beautiful object, admire it, but not use it—continuing to use the older model that already has a few scratches—until some weeks or months have passed, putting a psychological barrier of time between my impulse for acquisition and my surrender to daily use.

This is all sheer consumerism, of course. And my dilemma over nicks and scratches smacks of wanting to eat my cake and have it too. I wonder if our Paleolithic ancestors felt the same way about the tools of everyday life. Certainly not at the level of sharpening a stick and using it to kill game. But by the time people started etching patterns and applying colored glazes to the surface of their pots, they entered the realm of owning things too good for everyday use. And from that eventually came the middle class obsession with having “good” china and silverware versus the stainless steel flatware used in the kitchen, and “good” furniture in the drawing room versus the ramshackle stuff the kids can play on in the family room.

From there it’s just a short step to having a booming consumer market in car wax, clear vinyl, and iPhone covers.

1. It’s just as elegant on the inside, too. Turn it on—wake it up—and bright icons light the dark glass. The operating system is all touch-tap-swipe. And true to the promise, you don’t need an operating manual. Play with it for 15 minutes, and you just know how it works. As a product of conscientious development that adheres strictly to an underlying design ethos, the iPhone has no equal.

2. What can it do? See In the Palm of Your Hand from October 21, 2012, for my song of praises for multifunctionality. And if you ask why I’m still using the iPhone 4 and haven’t yet graduated to the 4S or 5, it’s because my current phone is still working perfectly and the new ones haven’t yet given me a compelling reason to move ahead—an odd position for me, a gadget freak who has bought into every new wave that came along. But there it is.

3. The one defect of the iPhone 4—corrected in subsequent models—was the susceptibility of the steel band, which functions as the antenna, to interference when contact with human skin creates a circuit across its insulating gaps. Cases cover the antenna and prevent this interference.

4. The same friend who puts his iPhone in an Otterbox once referred to the tiny scratches and wear marks on a used motorcycle as “character.” I instantly replied, “No, they’re damage.” We Thomas boys take care of our toys.

Sunday, July 28, 2013

Communicating with Aliens

One of the biggest questions facing humankind today—at least among those of us who were raised on science fiction and still concern ourselves with its propositions—is whether we humans are alone in the universe. And from that come a number of subsidiary questions: What will beings from another world look like? Will they be friendly explorers and traders or raiders and plunderers? How will we deal with them?

Science fiction has been divided on this issue. Everyone assumes that any self-aware entity able to cross the voids between the stars will have certain characteristics. They will be at least as intelligent—able to think and plan, use technology, identify and solve problems—as we are and probably more so. They will have power sources greater than ours and a technology likely more robust than ours. They will have a reason for coming here. And if they have any reason to bother with visiting humans on Earth, then they will have physical requirements based on conditions of gravity, atmosphere, and temperature—at the very least—which are similar to Earth’s. This tends to rule out giant space slugs that are born inside nebulae and travel between the stars naked to the vacuum of space under their own kinetic thrust. It also rules out vaporous membrane creatures who might be more at home in the swirling atmospheres of Jupiter and Saturn, or ice-crystal beings that would feel at home on Europa or Titan or out among the Oort Cloud.

But that still opens a lot of territory. H.G. Wells’s War of the Worlds proposed “vast, cool intelligences” in octopus-like bodies. Robert A. Heinlein’s Starship Troopers proposed arachnoid “bugs” with hive-like organization. Note that most of these representations are still drawing on elements of terrestrial anatomy: octopi that live in air rather than water, and spiders with human-scale intelligence or greater in bodies larger than ours.

Much science fiction, and especially that appearing in movies and on television, presents alien life forms born on other planets as basically humanoid. The invaders—because most of the encounters are hostile—are about our size and weight, move upon independently functioning limbs, have sensors clustered on one side of their brain cavities, and manipulate their technology with something approaching hands or paws or claws. And, of course, there’s the Star Trek universe, where everyone’s a humanoid of some description, usually identified by minor anatomical anomalies and skin coloring—things that can easily be applied in a makeup chair.1

Positing aliens as near-human is a useful plot device. It means that human readers and viewers can identify them as “the other” without guilt: close enough to human to be intelligible as evil-doers, but not so close that they deserve our respect and pity. In an age when we’ve finally realized that characters like Geronimo and his red Apache tribesmen, Shaka Zulu and his implacable black warriors, or Fu Manchu and his devilish yellow henchmen are genetically first cousins to the white Europeans who oppose them, and so should not be dismissed and demonized, we still need enemies that our fictional heroes can mow down with distain. Klingons, Romulans, and Cardassians will do for now. And when those humanoids have all been civilized and read into the Federation, there will always be zombies.

We’ve come a long way in the last two hundred years or so. Not only have we finally, officially recognized humans who have different habits of dress and hygiene, not to mention unusual religious and family lives, as basically the same as ourselves. We have also come to understand that we are not so different from this planet’s animals as well. Once we thought that any creature not capable of human speech, thought, and writing—that is, any animal—was inherently different from humans. We domesticated dogs, horses, and elephants but felt free to beat and kick them. We hunted whales for their blubber because it made good lamp oil. Yes, certain religions made icons of cats and jackals, monkeys and elephants, and granted to certain of their characteristics a human-like godhead. But we knew they were essentially different. We believed that humans, with our capability of self-recognition and self-awareness, with our ability to divide time into past, present and future—whereas most animals are presumed to live in an eternal now—and with our sophistications of language, writing, trade, and technology, were not just more advanced than the animals but intrinsically different. And better. We have immortal souls.

It was only in the last hundred years or so that we began to recognize intelligence as a spectrum. At one end are the single-celled creatures that can sense and react to a light source and avoid areas of damagingly high or low pH. Along about the middle of the spectrum are creatures like cats and dogs that can hunt for themselves, care for their young, groom themselves, sense danger, seek advantage, and perform other rudimentary survival tasks. Finally, out towards our end are creatures like the great apes that communicate in complex ways, use available tools to dig out food, set traps, and pass rudimentary discoveries from one individual to the next. And then, still on this scale but on the near end at the highest level of development, are the wondrous human beings, who speak in complete sentences with complex verb forms, wonder about the stars, build radio sets and rocket ships, and stand halfway to being angels and gods ourselves.

We still don’t know exactly what the family dog is thinking, but we assume that when it wags its tail and licks our hand, it’s certainly showing respect, possibly gratitude, and perhaps even the bonding of love. Many of us can read the shape of our dog’s mouth and just know that it’s smiling. We still can’t understand the language of dolphins and whales, but we sense a complexity in those repeated whoops and clicks that must be meaningful at some level. We can read the dances of bees and marvel that those tiny, hard-wired brains can send and receive such complex and pertinent messages.

But we are still limited in our appreciation of the senses. Most of us haven’t quite grasped that for many animals, sound and vocalization are not the mainstay of communication. Dogs read more complex messages about their world in scents than in barks. Bats see better with their ears, by echolocation, than with their eyes. Octopi and creatures living deep in the ocean communicate with colorful light shows that rival the marquees of Las Vegas casinos.

And yet these are all creatures with whom we share a basic chemical nature. I once suggested,2 that because every living creature on Earth shares the same DNA/RNA/protein coding mechanism, with no apparent evolution—that is, no competing systems left lying around that might use different chemicals or a different arrangement of the codons, suggesting evolved alternatives or experiments that once were tried and failed—then perhaps this complex DNA-based system actually developed somewhere else in the cosmos and either drifted into our solar system at the bacterial level, or was seeded here on purpose, or was left by accident—the “astronaut’s glove” hypothesis.

If life here on Earth is the product of some kind of bacterial seeding program, then we might meet our first aliens as some kind of distant cousin. They might be chemically similar to us. But their forms—the evolutionary branchings which on their native planet, with its own unique conditions, had chanced to arrive at superior intelligence and technical capability—might be no more similar to us than a tube worm or a turtle. All we can know by applying logic is that any cell-based life form would need to attain a certain size, a certain level of differentiation among its component cells, a level of complexity in their cohesion,3 and an expressed energy level that enables it to develop interpersonal communication and cooperation, technological sophistication, and the will and desire to travel which would enable them to cross the voids between the stars.

But if the DNA/RNA/protein system is unique to Earth, if any competing chemical systems have simply disappeared because the DNA system that won is so superior and the chemistries that lost simply dissolved in the rain, then all bets are off. Space-faring aliens would still need a level of complexity in cohesiveness and a level of energy expression to make complex decisions. But their organizing codons might be based on silicon chemistry rather than carbon chemistry. Their energy might come from breaking arsenate bonds rather than phosphate bonds. Or they might use some completely unique form of chemical organization. They might exhibit bizarre physical and mental characteristics and capabilities—or deficiencies—undreamed of in terrestrial life forms.

We might not be able to communicate with such aliens, given that we cannot yet communicate at any detailed level with our nearest carbon-based relatives, the great apes, dolphins, and whales. We might not even be able to recognize their motivations, let alone assign them any kind of morality, where discovery and trade equate with “good” and “benign” activities, while extermination and plunder equate with “bad” and “hostile,” just as we have a hard time assigning motivation to viruses, algae blooms, termites, and army ants. We might not even recognize these bizarre aliens as being alive.

The universe is a vast and varied place. We can expect to see signs and wonders. But we have to keep our eyes and ears, not to mention our imaginations, open and questioning. And after all that, wouldn’t it be disappointing if the first alien race we encountered were Vulcans with pointy ears, sugar-bowl haircuts, and a tinge of green makeup about their eyes?

1. I believe the producers once floated the idea—although I don’t have a reference for it—that all of these humanoids derived from a single strand of DNA that had scattered throughout the near quadrants of the galaxy and only later evolved these minor physical alterations on each world. This ignores the vast chemical similarity of human beings to all other life forms on Earth and our anatomical similarity to most land-based animals of the phylum Chordata.

2. See DNA is Everywhere from September 5, 2010.

3. Think of all the chemical signaling back and forth that allows various kinds of cells to function as a whole. For example, to initiate a simple process like blood clotting at a wound site requires a twelve-step cascade and interplay of various molecules so that the amount of clotting is proportional to the amount of damage.

Sunday, July 21, 2013

The Death of Nuclear Power

I was recently talking with a group of friends who are intelligent, well-read, and historically minded. They were surprised to hear my views on nuclear power, and I was equally surprised that they were surprised. It seems that in the long lull since the last time people rallied in opposition to nuclear power, we have conveniently forgotten a thing or two. And now some of the advocates of clean energy are promoting new and presumably safer reactor designs in order to address greenhouse gas concerns.

It ain’t gonna happen. For a variety of very good reasons, just … no.

America’s use of nuclear power for generating electricity started in the 1950s with the Atoms for Peace program under the Atomic Energy Commission. The AEC was a booster. They promoted atomic energy to public utilities as being “too cheap to meter”—that is, energy so clean, efficient, and inexpensive it would be a waste of time making people pay for it. This was also the time when the USS Nautilus sailed under nuclear power and crossed the North Pole beneath the ice. Plans were even afoot for nuclear-powered aircraft.1 I remember seeing a magazine article describing the wonders of nuclear fuel: the picture showed just a handful of these little black pellets, leaving the impression that the power plant, ship, or whatever could operate for months or years at a time on just those few magic beans.

The first commercial nuclear generating station in the United States was at Shippingport, Pennsylvania, and ran from 1958 to 1982. Since then, public utilities have built more than a hundred other reactors at 65 plant sites, producing about 20% of the country’s power needs at their peak. But they ordered no new nuclear plants after 1974, and by that time they were converting many of the nuclear units they had in the planning or construction stages to other fuels.2

Many people think the 1979 accident and partial core meltdown at Three Mile Island was the death of nuclear power, but the nuclear enterprise was on the ropes five years before then. The utilities had discovered that—rather than being too cheap to meter—nuclear power was too expensive to build and operate.

The first I knew of the problem was an article I read in Fortune magazine in 1968.3 It suggested that the energy conversion efficiency of nuclear fuel is less than one. That is, if you divide the energy you can get out of a bundle of manufactured fuel rods by the energy you must put into making that bundle, the result is a fraction less than one. You’ve just discovered a way to go broke slowly.

Making nuclear fuel is a complicated process. You first have to mine the ore and remove the rocky waste, converting the remainder into pure uranium oxide, U3O8, or yellowcake. Then you move the yellowcake to a concentration facility where you turn it into a heavy gas, uranium hexafluoride, UF6, and run it though high-speed centrifuges to separate the fissionable isotope U-235 from the more stable isotope U-238. Since U-235 is only about 0.72% of most naturally occurring uranium, you have to do a lot of concentrating, which consumes a lot of electricity. Finally, you convert the enriched gas into uranium metal, mold it into pellets, insert them into stainless-steel tubes inside a clay matrix, and bind the tubes into bundles with a specific configuration of the enclosed pellets. Needless to say, shaping and handling enriched uranium must be performed under precisely controlled conditions and generate a lot of low-level waste.

By the time you’ve done all that, you have put more energy into mining, trucking, converting, centrifuging, and manufacturing than you get out by radioactively fissioning—also called “burning”—the pellets. The only advantage to this tradeoff is that the pollution from this invested energy is spread out. You are burning diesel in excavators and trucks at mines out in the desert or in transporting the interim products along country roads, rather than burning coal or oil at your nice, clean nuclear plant in or near town.

And that power plant doesn’t come cheap, either. A gas-powered turbine or a coal-fired boiler may put out carbon dioxide and, in the case of coal or oil, soot. But if it has a breakdown, you only lose some of the plant operating time and have to repair some damaged equipment. A nuclear reactor, on the other hand, can go bad in astounding ways—not the great, glowing gopher burning through bedrock of “China syndrome” fame—but a mess of radioactive materials and hot pieces and parts that take a lot of cost and effort to clean up. And if your containment is compromised, an accident can release radioactive materials to the surrounding countryside.

Public utilities discovered that nuclear plants were far more expensive to build and maintain than any other power source. To give just one example, the rebar in the containment structure has to be tracked stage by stage, from manufacture through storage and shipping down to installation on the site, with a level of documentation that approaches the chain of custody for evidence in a criminal trial. Every weld in the plant piping has to be x-rayed and documented. Safety measures are complex and narrowly scrutinized. And everything is subject to observation and adjustment by federal inspectors who don’t always agree among themselves about best practices and interpretation of the rules. A “nuke” can be five or six times as expensive to build as a fossil fuel plant of comparable capacity.

And yes, the nuclear fuel will power it at full capacity for a long time—usually about a year and a half—before it needs refueling. But during that time the operator must keep a log of the wear on every pump, valve, and pipe and track every reported issue and problem. Then, during refueling, the utility doesn’t just change out the fuel rods but generally takes down and rebuilds the whole steam supply system and other plant systems. And during that rebuild, all the original construction documentation requirements are still in force.

By 1974, the utilities themselves had figured out that nuclear power was hardly worth it. They only completed the plants on order because of their sunk investment costs. By that time, too, the Atomic Energy Commission had been abolished and its functions handed over to two different agencies: the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, to manage the nuclear power plants in existence; and the Energy Research and Development Administration, to investigate new energy technologies. Three years later ERDA became the U.S. Department of Energy.

France and Japan make nuclear power work economically because they reprocess their spent fuel. Exhausted fuel rods still contain fissionable material. Some of the U-235 atoms haven’t split during criticality. Some of the U-238 atoms that leaven the fissionable material have had a few neutrons knocked off and so become unstable U-235, and some have picked up a proton and become fissionable plutonium, Pu-239. Reprocessing closes the nuclear fuel cycle by extracting these unused and newly created fissionable materials and putting them to use in new fuel rods. That extends the energy capacity of the previously mined and processed uranium.4 Recycling also creates low-level wastes such as the steel and clay from the disassembled rods and high-level wastes from the fission products, mostly radioactive strontium and cesium. Low-level waste can be packaged and buried. High-level waste is normally mixed with molten glass to render these isotopes chemically inert and then disposed of by burying in geologically stable ground.5

France also maximizes the efficiency of its nuclear resource by using a standardized design in all of the country’s plants and servicing them during refueling with a flying team of experts trained in the special skills required. Compare this to the U.S. practice, where two different basic reactor designs—from either Westinghouse or Brown & Root—are used indiscriminately, and the plants built around them are designed according to the whims and specifications of the parent utility. Refueling in the U.S. is a matter of temporarily turning the operating staff that knows the plant best into refueling and reconstruction experts.

Without disassembly and reprocessing, spent fuel rods must be stored in their existing form. These rod bundles are both thermally hot, because their residual radioactivity is a form of energy, as well as radiationally hot. The low-level waste in the rods—the steel and clay—have a radioactive half-life of between five years and a few dozen years, depending on the material and its exposure to high-energy neutrons. If these wastes were removed in reprocessing, they would be packaged and buried at one of three registered disposal sites in South Carolina, Utah, or Washington state, which currently take wastes from fuel processing and handling. The high-level waste—the spent fuel isotopes—have half-lives on the order of tens of thousands of years. If these wastes were removed in reprocessing, they would be vitrified (i.e., mixed with molten glass) and stored deep inside a stable geological formation like Yucca Mountain in Nevada.

However, in 1977 President Carter issued an executive order that deferred indefinitely the reprocessing of spent nuclear fuel, because it would add to the world’s stock of plutonium and might lead to proliferation of nuclear weapons. Unprocessed spent fuel rods might once have been stored in back-filled pits deep in tunnels at Yucca Mountain, but work on that facility was terminated by an act of Congress in 2011.

So now all the spent fuel removed from America’s hundred or so power reactors sits waiting. Initially, the hot rods are stored on site in highly filtered “swimming pools” until they thermally cool down.6 After that—and here “cool” is still a relative term—they can be stored above ground in dry casks. Neither is a permanent solution. Either form of storage requires continuous monitoring. And of course, once the nuclear power plant itself is decommissioned, the reactor vessel and the “hot” side of the nuclear steam supply system and associated facilities must either be disassembled as hundreds of tons of low-level waste or put into some kind of continuously monitored mothball state for hundreds of years.

The people working on Yucca Mountain were grappling with how to warn future generations—50,000 or 100,000 years from now, or roughly ten or twenty times the length of recorded human civilization—about the dangerous wastes stored below ground. “Go away. This is not a place to be. If you do try to enter here, you will fail and also be accursed. If you somehow succeed, then do not complain that you entered unwarned, nor bother us with your deathbed prayers. [signed] The Gods.”7 Without such a long-term solution, the utilities that once owned and operated nuclear power plants will have to remain as functioning entities, or be acquired by governments or charitable organizations that will remain functioning entities, for the next 100,000 years or so in order to monitor and protect these abandoned sites. Any bets on that happening?

Before any public utilities succumb once more to the siren song of “safe and clean” nuclear power that is “too cheap to meter,” they will need some iron-clad, rock-hard—and made of rock more durable than Yucca Mountain—guarantees from federal regulators that a solution to the waste problem will be found and made economically viable for them. Otherwise, nuclear fission is a nonstarter in this country.

What about nuclear fusion? Physicists and engineers have been promising practical nuclear fusion “within the next twenty years”—for at least the past thirty years. Whether by magnetic bottles or laser-blasted glass pellets filled with deuterium and tritium, you still have to put more energy into compressing the fuel than you get out from the fraction of hydrogen isotopes that actually fuse. And whether you are dealing with lines of magnetic force or angled laser beams, the problem seems to be uniformity in heating the fuel. Nothing works as consistently as the pressure of gravity, which is how the only sustained fusion reactions we know—those taking place inside the Sun and other stars—actually work. And if the fire could be successfully lit in a reactor on Earth, there would still be the problems of feeding in more fuel and extracting heat energy to drive a working fluid. Fusion energy is a long way off—if it ever becomes practical.

No, the government can run all the reactors it needs for aircraft carriers and submarines and nuclear weapons development. They have ways of preparing and monitoring those wastes. But no commercial energy corporation operating under the profit motive and with shareholders to protect will lift a finger to play again with such a dangerous and politically volatile resource.

1. It was to have been powered by a gas-cooled reactor. The entire plane would be radioactively “hot,” and the pilot—sitting in a lead-lined capsule—would be inserted and extracted through a hatch in the belly. No one’s thinking got so far ahead as to imagine what would happen if the plane ever crashed. Thankfully, the project was mothballed at the conceptual engineering stage.

2. With the promise of new and “inherently safer” designs coming into parlance about 2002, five new reactors at existing plant sites were ordered. The first of these is scheduled to come on line in 2020. However, with new natural gas and oil resources flooding the North American market, whether the owners will actually complete these units or convert them to cheaper fuels remains open to question.

3. And no, I do not have a reference.

4. For a while the federal government also experimented with fast breeder reactors. These are reactors designed to create nuclear fuel by turning large amounts of stable U-238 into fissionable U-235 and plutonium. One of the drawbacks, however, is that using water as a coolant slows down the fast neutrons that accomplish this trick. So, for cooling, they would have circulated liquid sodium metal. Of course, hot liquid sodium is a stage prop from Hell, and the potential for damage in case of a coolant leak was too great to contemplate.

5. The difference between low-level and high-level waste is simple. Low-level waste is normal material—the rod’s clay and steel, plus any tools and equipment used to handle fissionable materials—which has been exposed to high-level radiation so that its atoms have become unstable. They now kick off alpha and beta particles and gamma rays. These materials are dangerous to be around and will make you sick with prolonged exposure, but they will not make you or anything else in their vicinity in turn become radioactive. High-level waste is radioactive isotopes—the unstable uranium, strontium, and cesium—which in addition to alpha, beta, and gamma kick off high-energy neutrons. They will not only make you sick but will make you glow in the dark.

6. The water must be continually filtered because, while water itself is relatively inert and a good source of radioactive shielding, any dust or debris circulating in the pool would become highly radioactive.

7. To borrow a warning from Roger Zelazny’s delightful novel of the Buddha, Lord of Light.

Sunday, July 14, 2013

The Enlightenment and Easy Answers

Right now, western civilization is dealing—not entirely successfully—with a rise of Islamic politicization based on religious fundamentalism. We are concurrently dealing with a continuing streak of fundamentalism among some Christians—and this in the religion that has otherwise done much to shape our modern western views. The ensuing conflicts, both on a global and social scale, represent a problem that cannot be directly addressed by argument or appeals to reason. That means we in the West are headed for a frustrating couple of years—if not decades or even centuries.

First, let’s define the term “fundamentalism.” I take it to encompass those people who have gone back to their source materials—the Quran or the Bible—as the sole basis of their beliefs. They accept their respective religious texts as representing absolute truth, the word of God made visible. Religion necessarily plays a big part in their lives, and they believe that by adhering to its established, published view of the world they have arrived at an intellectual safety zone. To borrow a phrase, “God said it. I believe it. That settles it.” Not much to argue with there.

Why are these people so different from the rest of us western thinkers? I believe it’s because western civilization has passed through the period of intellectual turmoil in the 17th and 18th centuries called “the Enlightenment.” We came out the other side of this period with a new understanding. Fundamentalists either balk at the process or reject it outright.

To fundamentalists of any denomination, post-Enlightenment thinkers are “secularists,” “humanists,” or simply “unbelievers.” To them, we in the West put the interests of men before the commandments of God. We have become neglectful of our religion and decadent in our ways. We are lost in the darkness. The best they can say of us is that we are skeptics, doubters, blind fools who will not accept the truth that shines so obviously before our eyes.

But the driver of the Enlightenment is not skepticism or doubt for its own sake, which is general and undirected. Instead, the post-Enlightenment mind rejects easy answers and divine rationalizations in favor of the tested products of observation, logic, and quantification.

In the view of pre-Enlightenment clericalism, the world, the universe, and everything in it,1 are the work of a creator God who has set out a plan for its development through the end of time. Humans are created beings operating within that plan, and they differ from the beasts only in having rational minds and the ability to make choices and perform actions that are not in conformance with the plan. That is, they can act sinfully—in fact, the first sin, the original sin, was to eat of the tree of knowledge of good and evil that stood God’s perfect garden. By gaining knowledge, humankind infringed on God’s prerogative. The beasts and the rest of nature, on the other hand, have no such knowledge and so they innocently live according to the plan. The wise course, then, is for humans to remain obedient to the plan. Or, in the Islamic version, submit to the will of God.

In this view, much of the universe and the way it works is simply God’s business, meant to be mysterious, forever off limits to human understanding. We must accept the evidence of our eyes that the realm above the atmosphere, God’s realm, is perfect, filled with perfect, unchanging spheres following perfectly circular, unchanging orbits, with the stars affixed at some distance, and music filling all the space in between. Affairs down here on the planet are chaotic only because humans are disobedient, sinful, and blundering.

The Enlightenment marked a turning point in humankind’s intellectual development. Those two centuries saw a sudden flowering of human thought in mathematics, astronomy, physics, and chemistry.2 We began looking out, to that perfect world above the atmosphere, and inward, to the previously invisible world in drops of water and bits of everyday matter.3 We began a civilizational enterprise of attaining knowledge, not from the conjectures of priests and shamans, but from direct observation and the application of rational thought to what we saw.

Out of this collective effort came the greatest prize of the period, the Scientific Method. As an approach to knowledge, to bootstrapping our ideas and understanding, starting in a dark room full of ignorance, it cannot be surpassed. 1. Observe what’s actually going on around you, not what you think you should see or what you’ve been told to look for. 2. Question the what, why, and how of the everything you see, both in their static nature (what they are) and their current activities (how and why they operate). 3. Form a hypothesis—or an informed guess—as to what may be happening. 4. Think of an experiment, limited both in scope and scale, which will test that hypothesis by trying to prove it wrong. 5. Predict the outcome of that experiment if the hypothesis happens to be correct. 6. Perform the experiment and report your results accurately so that others may try it for themselves. 7. Modify your hypothesis and repeat Steps 3 through 6 as necessary.

The Scientific Method rejects any calls to orthodoxy—except in terms of its own strict requirements. It recognizes no authority or consensus or appeals to “common knowledge,” folklore, ethnic or societal imperatives, or deeply held beliefs. It supposes—perhaps as part of its own deeply held belief system—that everything has a cause, rather than a purpose in some pre-established plan; that observation and logic can find and prove the answers to any set of questions; and that nothing in the universe—and now perhaps even outside of it—lies beyond the human mind’s ability to ultimately know and understand.

The Scientific Method ignited a voyage of discovery that continues to this day and will probably last until our civilization falls into apathy or chaos. It has opened realms of knowledge and technology that either never existed before, or existed only in the imagination: powerful engines and energy sources, new materials like aluminum alloys and plastics, transmission of information through the air, moving people and cargo by flying them far above ground level, traveling easily across oceans and under water, curing age-old diseases, analyzing and describing the molecular nature of life itself … the list goes on and on, indicating how different the life of the 21st century is from that of the 15th. And discoveries and changes in the future will only be more incredible.

Western thinkers who are still believers in a God and His plan for us, yet who accept the premise of the Scientific Method and the discoveries emanating from the Enlightenment, must modify their beliefs. As science has opened a wider sky and an older creation, full of billions of galaxies each filled with billions of stars, each with the potential for churning out a different kind of life, believers must adopt a longer viewpoint and a less personal approach to God as He is found in the Bible or Quran. For example, they must reinterpret the Bible’s creation story, encompassing a mere six days, as representing the limited understanding of its human authors rather than an accurate depiction divine achievement. They must seek the essence of the religion and let go of the exact details as described in scripture.

More than that, the post-Enlightenment mind is forced to accept partial and provisional answers. The modern view is that, while all questions may ultimately be answered, some exist for which the answers are still waiting to be found, either because we are starting in the wrong place, or because the answers lie at a deeper level of complexity than we have yet penetrated. Some mysteries are only partially unraveled. And sometimes each discovery only shows that the complexity of life and the universe goes much deeper than we first thought.

Even when we suspect that some scientists might be barking up the wrong tree,4 we accept that barking is a valid exercise and that the right tree is out there waiting to be found.

Accepting the Enlightenment means being able to tolerate messy solutions and conclusions, a scenario that’s still developing, and uncertainty about the final outcome. Not everything has to be perfect and harmonious. We in the western tradition now prefer a riddle and a solidly proven, if inexact and incomplete, finding (e.g., the irresolvable number pi, the fractal nature of the universe) over a neat and perfect answer that requires an invisible and unprovable divine author (e.g., perfect circles and finite numbers). We know that perfection is a product of the human mind and imagination, not what is happening in the real world.

Accepting the Enlightenment is a kind of faith: in the enterprise of science to uncover the ultimate mysteries and the capability of the human mind to finally understand them and use them wisely. In this view, humans are not sinful, fallen beings, but seeking and ascending intelligences.

The Scientific Method is the projection of a system of thought forward into chaos. It represents a preference for some measure of barely understood chaos over a neat and comforting priestly story that we know or suspect may not be so.

1. And it’s a small place, with the Earth at the center, the Moon, the Sun, and the planets circling around it affixed to nested celestial spheres, and the thousands of stars hanging like candles in wall sconces on the furthermost sphere. It was created in its current form a long time ago—it’s almost 6,000 years old!—and has not changed much since.

2. And some, like Sir Isaac Newton, made discoveries in all three branches of knowledge. It was a time of geniuses and polymaths.

3. Interestingly, good optics in the form of ground and polished glass lenses set in the newly invented telescopes and microscopes formed the basis of our observational peerings in both directions.

4. See The Unriddling of Quantum Bayesianism from June 9, 2013, as well as my previous blogs that challenge some aspects of science and mathematics. I have never denied the validity of the scientific enterprise itself, merely questioned some of its outlying positions which court rational absurdities.